Tickle Me Elmo Plush Top 10 Christmas Toys 1996

Tickle Me Elmo Plush Top 10 Christmas Toys 1996

The Tickle Me Elmo Plush of 1996 became one of the most notorious toy crazes of the decade. Based on the lovable red character from Sesame Street, this interactive plush doll laughed, shook, and wiggled when squeezed. For children unwrapping him on Christmas morning, Elmo wasn’t just a toy—he was a giggling friend who brought joy, laughter, and a touch of chaos into living rooms everywhere.

1996: A Year in Context

1996 in the UK was a year dominated by pop culture phenomena—from the Spice Girls to Euro 1996. Toy crazes were at their peak, and parents were all too familiar with the scramble to secure the hottest item. Tickle Me Elmo fit perfectly into this environment, sparking one of the first true toy “frenzies” of the modern retail era.

A Laughing Sensation

Elmo, already beloved from Sesame Street, came to life in 1996 thanks to his clever design. Squeeze his belly and he would chuckle, giggle, and shake in delight. Children adored the contagious laughter, which seemed to spread to everyone in the room. The simplicity of the concept—combined with the power of a popular character—made it irresistible (see Tickle Me Elmo history).

Christmas Morning Excitement

Parents recall children hugging Elmo and immediately bursting into laughter as the toy shook in their arms. Many recall the sound of Elmo’s giggle echoing through the house all Christmas Day, with kids repeatedly pressing his belly for more. He quickly became a constant companion, spreading happiness wherever he went.

The Frenzy

By December 1996, Tickle Me Elmo had become almost impossible to find. News outlets reported scenes of parents queuing overnight, fighting over the last dolls on shelves, and paying inflated prices in the second-hand market. The craze was so intense that it became a cultural event in itself, cementing Elmo’s place in toy history.

Price Then and Now

In 1996, the Tickle Me Elmo Plush retailed for around £29.99, or about £60 today. Its resale value soared to hundreds of pounds as desperate parents tried to get one before Christmas. Today, original 1996 Elmo dolls are collectors’ items, while later versions and re-releases continue to keep the giggling red character alive.

Why Kids Loved It

Children loved Elmo because he felt alive. His infectious laugh and shaking body made him more than a plush doll—he was a friend who responded to their touch. The joy he brought was immediate and repeatable, making him endlessly entertaining. For many kids, he was a source of comfort and laughter rolled into one.

Nostalgia and Legacy

For adults who grew up in the nineties, Tickle Me Elmo remains one of the most memorable toys ever released. People recall the laughter, the chaos in shops, and the pride of finally owning one. His legacy continues as both a symbol of toy mania and a reminder of how simple joy can capture the world’s imagination.

1996 Christmas Memories

Families remember the frenzy to secure Elmo and the overwhelming joy when he appeared under the tree. Parents recall the lengths they went to in order to find one, while children remember the giggles that filled the house. For many, Christmas 1996 was defined by the sound of Elmo’s laughter echoing through the living room.

Conclusion

The Tickle Me Elmo Plush of 1996 was more than just a toy—it was a phenomenon. With his infectious giggle and cuddly charm, Elmo created one of the most memorable toy crazes of the decade. If you remember hugging Elmo until your sides hurt from laughter, revisit the magic in our Top 10 Christmas Toys 1996 archive. See how he compares with the most popular Christmas toys, and explore how toy crazes continue in our Top 10 Christmas Toys 2025 guide. Elmo will forever be remembered as the red, giggling star of Christmas 1996.

Some links on our site are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a small commission — at no extra cost to you. 🎄